Cavb.org is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more

Best Keurig Reusable Filter Of 2024

Brandon Forder
  Apr 27, 2024 2:02 PM

The controversy over paper versus reusable filters has raged on for years, and I refuse to take sides. Many individuals think paper filters do a better job of removing unwanted oils and making coffee taste more refined. Conversely, reusable coffee filters save money over time.

There are only a few things to consider when shopping for reusable coffee filters: the type of material to buy, the lifespan of the filters, and whether or not the filters are compatible with your coffee machine. Use this list of the best reusable coffee filters to narrow down your search.


Compare Products

Last update on 2024-04-27 / Affiliate links / Images, Product Titles, and Product Highlights from Amazon Product Advertising API


Buying Guide

Material

Keurig cups are constructed from plastic and stainless steel. To reduce your risk of exposure to harmful chemicals, use BPA-free, eco-friendly plastic models.

In most cases, the ratio of stainless steel to plastic will be the main point of differentiation. The K-cup basket of some models is composed of stainless steel mesh, whereas the lid and frame are made of plastic. While some, instead of using stainless steel mesh, use a stainless steel basket with perforated holes. They may have a plastic cover, but these types are predominantly metal. Both the metal and plastic varieties are equally effective.

Stainless steel baskets are more expensive but can tolerate the heat of dishwashers better than plastic ones. However, if cared for properly, either variety can last for many years.

K-cup performance is heavily dependent on the coffee maker itself; some K-cups, specifically those with a stainless steel basket, are more reliably compatible with specific makers. Manufacturers of reusable K cups often indicate which machines are suitable for use with their items.

Capacity

The standard amount of coffee grounds for a 6-8 ounce cup of coffee is 2 teaspoons (10 grams). If you use a larger cup, though, the result will be more concentrated.

In any case, if you want to reuse your Keurig cup, don't fill it to to the brim. While using more coffee grounds may provide for stronger coffee, using too much will result in water being unable to permeate the grounds, rendering the coffee weak. It can also cause the head to become blocked, rendering your machine useless.

Materials

Reusable The plastic and stainless steel components of Keurig cups are mixed in varying proportions according on the manufacturer. To prevent harmful chemicals from seeping into your coffee, look for models made with BPA-free plastic and without a negative impact on the environment.

Some models will have a plastic cover and frame, while others may have a plastic lid and frame with a stainless steel mesh. There are also types that use a basket made of solid stainless steel with perforated holes in place of mesh.

All of them are serviceable, however the best option depends on the user. More expensive, but likely to endure longer if made entirely of stainless steel.

Mesh Size 

The coarseness or smoothness of the grind, and hence the taste of the coffee, is determined by the mesh size of the K cup.

The finer the grounds, the better they'll function with a finer mesh, which means a more intense flavor. If you're trying to keep the grounds out of your coffee, a finer mesh is more effective.

Coarse grinds and longer extraction periods from coffee makers benefit from a wider mesh. With a coarser grind, more time must pass for the water to permeate the grinds and extract the whole taste. A finer grind is necessary for a machine that extracts more quickly. Thus, the machine in question determines the optimal mesh size. Whether you're using a French press, drip coffee maker, or another type of coffee maker, a grind that falls somewhere in the middle of the mesh size spectrum works best for your normal generic coffee equipment.

Several other variables besides mesh size affect the final flavor of the coffee. These include the grind, the duration and temperature of the extraction process, and the quality of the coffee itself. No matter what size mesh your K cup has, it takes practice to make the ideal cup of coffee. You can, however, choose a mesh size that works well with your chosen roast and grind if you have a good idea of what those are.

For the best taste, use a fine-mesh reusable K cup and your preferred dark roast coffee or espresso beans, especially if your machine has a short extraction time. The fine grind and fine mesh work together to prevent grounds from entering the coffee while allowing for an optimal flavor extraction. The flavor is more akin to espresso than that of a regular cup of coffee.

Compatibility

Keurig is responsible for popularizing K cups. It's important to note that not all reusable K cups are compatible with all Keurig machines, even among different versions of the same brand. Some reusable K cups may only be compatible with certain machines, and that's true even within the same brand. The manufacturers of reusable K cups typically provide a list of compatible equipment. If you want to make sure that your reusable K cups are compatible with your machine, check this list.

Durability

Used coffee pods should be durable enough to be reused. They must be able to survive the high temperatures of the washing machine and dishwasher, as well as soak up the occasional spill without becoming brittle or falling apart.

Moving parts

Even a reusable k-cup should be simple to operate. It becomes more of a hassle and more likely that a lost component will be one of the pod's many extra elements if there are more of them. Choose the reusable k-cup that doesn't need any pre-use disassembly or reassembly if you value simplicity.

Price

There is a wide range in price for reusable k-cup filters, but some are certainly more cost-effective than others. Even though buying a reusable pod for your Keurig can save you money on disposable caps over time, the initial investment may be prohibitive for some.

The cheapest ones are likely to be less sturdy and will break more easily, but if you won't be using it much, they may suffice.


FAQS

How much coffee should I put in a reusable K cup?

Ground coffee can be placed in a reusable K cup to the extent of two tablespoons. Some designs use dual fill lines to accommodate various cup sizes. However, such variants typically only work with particular pieces of equipment.

Do you need filters for reusable K cups?

Filters made of paper are unnecessary. However, some reusable K-cups benefit from adding paper filters to prevent grounds from contaminating the brew. This is especially true when using coarsely ground coffee.

Do I need any accessories?

It's up to you to decide if the extras that are along with some reusable K cups are necessary. There could be a paper filter or a scoop included. A tiny mesh strainer is all that's required to keep coffee grinds out of your cup, and this reusable filter adds further garbage to the mix. But if you're filling a tiny cup, a coffee scoop will come in helpful so you don't waste any grounds.

Why does my reusable K-Cup make weak coffee?

Coffee that has been diluted by using too fine of grounds is not very good coffee. If the cup isn't filled to the appropriate level, the final product may be weaker than desired. However, these cups have a limited capacity, and if you try to cram too much in, you won't get the best possible result. If you prefer a stronger cup of coffee from your Keurig, you might also experiment with darker roasts or more robust flavors.


Conclusion

Reusable K Cup filters are usually effective and much more eco-friendly than K-Cup pods that are only used once. They have a low total cost of ownership over time, which boosts their desirability as an investment. The best aspect is that they improve the taste of the coffee more than the standard K-Cup pods, which tend to trap the aroma of the coffee inside their plastic shells. Instead, the coffee's flavor bursts forth with none of the oils being compromised.


4
2 ratings